The Menzingers

Everything I Ever Saw

Item: Everything I Ever Saw
Rating: 4.7
Author: Pitchfork

4.7 Pitchfork score: 4.7/10

Reviewed 22 July 2026 by Eli Enis

Genre Rock

→ Explore every Pitchfork review on The Fork — 28,293 reviews, searchable by score, genre, decade & reviewer.

The Fork aggregates publicly available album reviews. Not affiliated with Pitchfork or Condé Nast.